top of page
Post_Page_Header.webp
  • Writer's pictureThe Underwear Review

The Most Comfortable T-Shirts for Men 2024

The most highly sought-after characteristic in t-shirts: Comfort.

Man wearing comfortable t-shirt.

This installment in our Most Comfortable Underwear Series is all about the most comfortable t-shirts for men.


And when we use the term comfortable, you might be wondering what level of comfort we’re actually talking about here.


To make our Most Comfortable List, we’re talking about t-shirts that fit like a second skin.


A shirt that you’re happy to put on and then forget you’re even wearing levels of comfort.


Now, of course, we know that men come in all different shapes and sizes, not to mention have different preferences when it comes to fit, fabric type, etc.


For this reason, it’s difficult to promise that each t-shirt listed here is going to fit and feel perfect to you.


So, while there may be some scrolling and a little trial and error involved, we’re confident that you’ll find an incredibly comfortable t-shirt on this list that fits just right and becomes your new favorite.



How We Make Our Picks for Most Comfortable T-Shirt

 

Look, we get it.


Determining what makes for a great t-shirt can be a pretty subjective thing.

 

So, how do we decide which ones make our list for the most comfortable? 

 

We tested a wide range of t-shirts from leading menswear brands and put them through the rigors of daily life and active situations.

 

And, as a result, we can say for certain that 3 specific qualities make for an objectively more comfortable t-shirt experience.


Testing high-quality t-shirts for comfort.
Reviewing t-shirts from leading menswear brands.

 

1. Premium fabric blends that support active bodies.

 

You move your body in a wide range of motion throughout the day and it doesn’t take much for it to overheat or experience distracting irritation.

 

We prioritized options with naturally soft and breathable fabrics that add a touch of stretch (i.e. spandex, elastane, etc.).

 

We’ve also found that while you may end up paying a little more for premium fabric, it tends to stay in better shape for longer.

 

 

2. Versatile fit that provides comfort and style. 

 

T-shirts take on a wide variety of roles in our everyday lives from layering staple to relaxed loungewear to standalone statement.

 

While it’s impossible to find a single t-shirt that can fill every role, certain options utilize features that boost versatility and bridge the gap between comfort, function, and style. 

 

T-shirts that add spandex stretch to the fabric blend help to retain its shape over time, enhance your mobility, and can be worn in a number of different scenarios.

 

 

3. Design features that optimize layering.

 

Wear it layered or on its own, a great t-shirt can do it both.

 

A smooth fit is key here, so look for t-shirts that eliminate excess fabric, forego unnecessary features, and use chafe-free seaming details.

 

We went with t-shirt brands that understand these crucial details and know how to deliver a smooth-fitting t-shirt that works with your body, even if it’s under layers.


The Underwear Review testing the 2(X)IST Dream T-Shirt.
Testing the 2(X)IST Dream Crew Neck T-Shirt.

Here, you can see us testing one of our top picks, the 2(X)IST Dream T-Shirt, which features all three of these key qualities. 

 

1. Fabric: Pima cotton and modal for a dreamy fit and feel.


2. Versatile: Added stretch for enhanced mobility and stylish color options.


3. Features: Classic fit with a tagless design and naturally breathable fabric.  



Note: Featured products are independently selected and reviewed by The Underwear Review. If you purchase through our links, we may earn commission.



1. Tommy John Second Skin Tee


The Tommy John Second Skin Tee features an incredibly soft premium fabric that’s non-pilling, fade-free, and is a Tommy John top seller. This t-shirt utilizes a signature Memory Fabric that’s unshrinkable and wrinkle-resistant.


Man wearing Tommy John Second Skin Tee.

Shop at Tommy John: Tommy John Second Skin Tee


Tommy John’s Second Skin Tee features an extra comfortable fabric blend of pima cotton, modal, and a bit of spandex for stretch. This t-shirt has a non-boxy modern fit that’s designed to move with your body.


Our Favorite Feature: Non-pilling premium fabric that’s incredibly soft.



2. Mack Weldon Pima Crew Neck T-Shirt


The Mack Weldon Pima Crew Neck T-Shirt features an incredibly soft 100% pima cotton fabric in a flattering slim fit. This versatile t-shirt works great for both layering and wearing alone.


Man wearing Mack Weldon Pima Crew Neck T-Shirt.


Mack Weldon’s Pima Crew Neck T-Shirt utilizes a recovery collar crew neck design and strong ladder stitching for durability. This t-shirt undergoes a softening enzyme wash for an unbeatably soft feel.


Our Favorite Feature: Incredibly soft 100% pima cotton fabric.



3. 2(X)IST Dream Crew Neck T-Shirt


The 2(X)IST Dream Crew Neck T-Shirt is the perfect blend of pima cotton and modal fabric for an unbelievably soft and comfortable feel. This undershirt utilizes premium fabric with added stretch for enhanced mobility that fits and feels like a dream.


Man wearing 2(X)IST Dream Crew Neck T-Shirt.


2(X)IST’s Dream Crew Neck T-Shirt has a classic fit that’s tagless and breathable. This undershirt has a luxurious feel that’s great for lounging and extended wear.


Our Favorite Feature: Pima cotton and modal fabric for a dreamy fit and feel.



4. Zimmerli Sea Island Luxury Cotton T-Shirt


The Zimmerli Sea Island Luxury Cotton T-Shirt is made from 100% Sea Island Cotton and far from your average t-shirt. This t-shirt is incredibly soft and lightweight while remaining durable for repeated wears.


Man wearing Zimmerli Sea Island Luxury Cotton T-Shirt.


Zimmerli’s Sea Island Luxury Cotton T-Shirt has a wider fit crew neckline for a comfortable and stylish fit and works great for both wearing alone or layering.


Our Favorite Feature: Incredibly soft 100% Sea Island Cotton.



5. David Archy Bamboo Rayon Stretch T-Shirt


The David Archy Bamboo Rayon Stretch T-Shirt features a high-end bamboo rayon fabric that’s incredibly soft, breathable, and lightweight. This t-shirt sports a touch of spandex stretch for enhanced elasticity and the perfect fit.


Man wearing David Archy Bamboo Rayon Stretch T-Shirt.

15% Off Discount Code: TheUR

 

David Archy’s Bamboo Rayon Stretch T-Shirt works great as a base layer with a perfect stay-tucked length and strong sweat absorbing fabric. This t-shirt comes in a convenient 3-pack with several available color options.

 

Our Favorite Feature: Incredibly soft, breathable, and lightweight bamboo rayon fabric.

 

 

6. All Citizens EcoSilver T-Shirt


The All Citizens EcoSilver T-Shirt pairs powerful performance features with an incredibly soft everyday feel. This t-shirt utilizes a comfortable microfiber fabric that’s sweat-wicking, quick-drying, and breathable.


Man wearing All Citizens EcoSilver T-Shirt.

Shop at All Citizens: All Citizens EcoSilver T-Shirt

 

All Citizens’s EcoSilver T-Shirt sports 360° stretch, anti-odor silver, and a wrinkle-resistant design for a t-shirt that stays fresh and looks great through activity and all-day wear. This t-shirt is available in 3 classic color choices.

 

Our Favorite Feature: Soft microfiber fabric with anti-odor silver for stay-fresh comfort.

 

 

7. All Citizens Re:Luxe Essential T-Shirt


The All Citizens Re:Luxe Essential T-Shirt features a luxuriously soft Re:Luxe performance microfiber fabric with 360° stretch and anti-odor technology. This t-shirt sports a stylish matte finish in a wrinkle-resistant design.


Man wearing All Citizens Re:Luxe Essential T-Shirt.

 

All Citizens’ Re:Luxe Essential T-Shirt provides a weightless feel that’s sweat-wicking, quick-drying, and breathable. This t-shirt has a premium feel at half the price and is available in many color options.

 

Our Favorite Feature: Luxuriously soft Re:Luxe performance fabric.



8. Allbirds Allgood Cotton Tee


The Allbirds Allgood Cotton Tee features an extra soft 100% organic cotton in an everyday fit that drapes just right on your body.


Man wearing Allbirds Allgood Cotton Tee.

Shop at Allbirds: Allbirds Allgood Cotton Tee


Allbirds’ Allgood Cotton Tee has a crewneck design in a classic fit that hits at the hips and is available in multiple colors.


Our Favorite Feature: 100% organic cotton in comfortable everyday fit.



9. Alo Yoga Triumph Crew Neck Tee


The Alo Yoga Triumph Crew Neck Tee features a soft tri-blend jersey fabric and is designed to handle movement from studio to street. This t-shirt has a slim yet relaxed fit that’s both stylish and incredibly versatile.


Man wearing Alo Yoga Triumph Crew Neck Tee.


Alo Yoga’s Triumph Crew Neck Tee features a classic crewneck design, raglan sleeves, and has an extra soft feel that’s great for all day wear.


Our Favorite Feature: Designed for movement with soft tri-blend jersey fabric.



10. Proof 72-Hour Merino Tee


The Proof 72-Hour Merino Tee features a high-performance merino wool fabric that’s incredibly soft, durable, and odor-resistant for up to 3 days (72 hours) of nonstop wear. This t-shirt is naturally moisture-wicking, temperature regulating, and odor-resistant.


Man wearing Proof 72-Hour Merino Tee.

Shop at Huckberry: Proof 72-Hour Merino Tee


Proof’s 72-Hour Merino Tee utilizes nylon reinforcement for its merino fabric that allows for shape retention and easy garment care. This t-shirt has a stylish cut and performance design that doesn’t sacrifice comfort.


Our Favorite Feature: Performance design that doesn’t sacrifice comfort.



11. Bombas Pima Cotton Crew Neck T-Shirt


The Bombas Pima Cotton Crew Neck T-Shirt has a naturally cool feel with 100% pima cotton to help you stay fresh all day. This t-shirt features a mid-weight construction for improved durability and a natural hang.


Man wearing Bombas Pima Cotton Crew Neck T-Shirt.


Bombas’ Pima Cotton Crew Neck T-Shirt utilizes a unique cross-stitching technique and a tag free neckline for an extra comfortable wear. This t-shirt is available in extended sizes and designed to look good on everyone.


Our Favorite Feature: 100% pima cotton with naturally cool feel.



12. Forty Five Supima Crew Tee


The Forty Five Supima Crew Tee has a classic look with thoughtful craftsmanship and features an incredibly soft 100% USA-grown supima cotton. This t-shirt has a timeless tailored sleeve and is the perfect length for both tucked and untucked looks.


Man wearing Forty Five Supima Crew Tee.

Shop at Huckberry: Forty Five Supima Crew Tee


Forty Five’s Supima Crew Tee has a simple and versatile design that can layered or worn on its own. This t-shirt is garment-dyed for additional softness and preshrunk for an ideal ready-to-wear fit.


Our Favorite Feature: Supima cotton for a smooth, soft, and long-lasting fabric.



13. Pair of Thieves SuperSoft Tee


The Pair of Thieves SuperSoft Tee utilizes a signature SuperSoft cotton and modal fabric with 4-way stretch. This undershirt has a comfortable and classic design in a flattering fit.


Man wearing Pair of Thieves SuperSoft Crew Neck Tee.

Shop at Pair of Thieves: Pair of Thieves SuperSoft Tee


Pair of Thieves’ SuperSoft Tee is a comfy and versatile option that both layers well and looks great on its own. This undershirt is tagless and comes with a No Regrets Guarantee.


Our Favorite Feature: SuperSoft fabric with 4-way stretch.



14. Rhone Reign T-Shirt


The Rhone Reign T-Shirt features a soft nylon polyester jersey blend for a broken-in feel with sweat-wicking performance.


Man wearing Rhone Reign T-Shirt.

Available on Amazon: Rhone Reign T-Shirt


Rhone’s Reign T-Shirt has comfortable 4-way stretch, straddle stitching for chafe-free seams, and raglan sleeves for improved movement and overall fit. Available in multiple colors.

Our Favorite Feature: Broken-in comfort with performance features.



15. J. Crew Broken-In Short-Sleeve T-Shirt


The J. Crew Broken-In Short-Sleeve T-Shirt is their all-time favorite tee first introduced in 2004. This t-shirt features a comfortable cotton fabric that’s specially washed for softness to feel like one of your well-worn favorites.


Man wearing J. Crew Broken-In Short-Sleeve T-Shirt.


J. Crew’s Broken-In Short-Sleeve T-Shirt is garment-dyed twice and specially washed for a lived-in color that looks great from the very first wear.


Our Favorite Feature: Specially washed for softness and lived-in color.



And if you’re all about comfort when it comes to your shirts, socks, and underwear be sure to check out the rest of our Most Comfortable Series.

Comments


Most Comfortable Series

Best Picks on Amazon

David_Archy_Banner.jpg
Sep Ad.jpg
Learn about the author.
bottom of page